Received-SPF: pass (Last token {mx} (res=PASS)) client-ip=46.226.110.80; envelope-from=<john@wilkes.com>; x-ip-name=mx.wilkes.com;
X-Received: from wilkes.com (mx.wilkes.com [46.226.110.80])
by netwin.co.nz (SurgeMail 7.4d) with ESMTP id 17466000-1391920
for <surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz>; Mon, 25 Nov 2019 21:07:29 +0000
X-Return-Path: john
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=wilkes.com;
s=default; t=1574716049;
bh=CBDfXYV1b+YVhP4NBRD8MsGjxW/2osSdo+X3cLY2e6k=;
h=Subject:From:To:References:Date:In-Reply-To;
b=KA/OsoTbOpTkOBCj0w+E/cOs4XfaZEZDwf6TwZHG8I3C77RIQzvEowm7jYxvaGfzf
kgJv2VmUmRVfxgCfoY757vZR6bvS0snJULb7jCfcyOD6WI5RvV5Wkbbm9GU/BDfYqO
zyHZbWzWNKoNKBagyd6KBauG7n/C3ClpFJBLTAN6xR1bqEvJ0sV2EzKQwmzkkT55WT
Ttpnh0oKF3zmWrfx0XllidAJU/IjdFeHIL9hROiU8w3l8yLcd7g64+Gw/5Oa4iVVN0
YAIfpWuCTJVfF/RFlVGuV961DYJq9DLZeGE7zZxu4uJEyjrnm7vlcJZzHFIiMglsMH
Tf0gtiq5wT63w==
X-Default-Received-SPF: pass (skip=forwardok (res=PASS));
Subject: Re: [SurgeMail List] filter set to "reject" but incoming email still
delivered
From: John Wilkes
To: surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz
References: <5ddc348f.341c.6514700.12060fcf@netwin.co.nz>
<45b868cb-2ca6-ead1-c51f-0fc6b9aca962@wilkes.com>
Autocrypt: addr=john@wilkes.com; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=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 2A==
Message-ID: <2bcea04c-6767-f0cf-2470-78eb3a44014a@wilkes.com>
Date: Mon, 25 Nov 2019 13:07:26 -0800
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.12; rv:68.0)
Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.2.2
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <45b868cb-2ca6-ead1-c51f-0fc6b9aca962@wilkes.com>
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
X-X-Authenticated-User: john@wilkes.com
X-Originating-IP: 46.226.110.80
X-Country: code=LU country="Luxembourg" ip=46.226.110.80
X-Rcpt-To: <surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz>
X-Kann: +OK 0.823 0.976 4/14
X-SpamDetect: ***: 3.7 sd=3.7 lv=0.00 nok=6/0 m=3 nf=0 Close 0.04(X-myrbl:Color=white) 0.90(X-Phrase:isspam) 0.16(X-SpamContent:clean) 0.74(X-Verify-Helo:-ERR) 0.71(X-Verify-Helo:wrongip) 0.36(spfpass) 0.38(X-NotAscii:utf) 0.39(StandardTLD) 0.48(X-LangGuess:English) Saned 5.0 Sval 3.7 bsan 5.0 Moved 5.0->3.7 Sval 3.7
X-NotAscii: charset=utf-8
X-SpamContent: Clean
X-LangGuess: English
X-Probe: +OK skipped, known ip address
X-Phrase: IsSpam score=1.00
X-Verify-Helo: -ERR wrongip: wilkes.com -> 217.70.*.* not in 46.226.110.80
Authentication-Results: netwin.co.nz header.from=john@wilkes.com; dkim=fail (Unable to verify)
X-MyRbl: Color=White Age=638 Spam=0 Notspam=0 Stars=0 Good=82 Friend=122 Surbl=0 Catch=0 r=0 ip=46.226.110.80
X-IP-stats: Incoming Outgoing Last 0, First 625, in=31424, out=307, spam=0 Known=true ip=46.226.110.80
List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:surgemail-list-leave@netwin.co.nz?subject=unsubscribe>
X-Mailing-List: surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz
List-ID: <surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz>
Precedence: bulk
Reply-To: surgemail-list@netwin.co.nz
On the Friends - Settings page:
"Friends is applied after your Filters and after your Spam rules. Friends address list is applied after your Filters and before your Spamrules."
This is not the behavior I see, and that you confirm. Friends is applied BEFORE filters, not after, as implied above.
Currently running SurgeMail Version 7.3o4-4, so maybe this has been corrected in a more recent release.
John
On 11/25/19 12:33 PM, John Wilkes wrote:
> Thanks for the reply and explanation. The user had sent a message to the address, and it was automatically added to the user's friends list. The the user added a filter to reject messages from that address, but it didn't work. I then tried to globally block the domain, but that didn't work, either. Now I know why. :-)
>
> I removed the address from the user's friends list and disabled automatically adding outgoing addresses.
>
> On 11/25/19 12:07 PM, Support ChrisP wrote:
>> Indeed no, the friends list is an over-ride for almost all situations. This is very much intentional.
>>
>> You can enforce a rule by using mfilter.rul to reject the message.
>>
>> ChrisP.
>>
>>
>>
>> On Tuesday 26/11/2019 at 5:43 am, John Wilkes wrote:
>>> I added domain and global filter entries to reject messages from a domain, but incoming email from that domain is still delivered. The log file indicates that the email was accepted because the sender is on the recipient's "friends" list.
>>>
>>> Shouldn't a global or domain setting override an individual user's setting?
>
>
--
John Wilkes
john@wilkes.com
There are two ways of surviving: production or theft. Either you produce what you need, or you take it from someone else. You can, of course, get the government to take it from someone else and give it to you, but it's still theft, just with the government doing the dirty work for you. ~Paul Rosenberg
|